Maine's AG, 19 others, officially opposes Trump Administration guidance that encourages agencies to ignore Climate Change

08/27/2019 
By Ramona du Houx

Maine's Attorney General Aaron M. Frey today joined a coalition of 19 attorneys general in filing a comment letter opposing the Council of Environmental Quality's (CEQ) draft guidance on consideration of greenhouse gas emissions under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA).
"Greenhouse gas emissions are proven to have a harmful effect on Maine's environment, economy, and quality of life," said Frey. "By encouraging agencies to ignore climate change when they review decisions under NEPA, the Trump Administration is unlawfully encouraging regulators to ignore evidence which could lead to harmful health impacts and financial costs in the future." 
NEPA serves as the cornerstone of America's environmental regulatory framework and requires agencies to consider environmental impacts, including greenhouse gas emissions and the effects of climate change, as part of their decision-making process. The requirement to consider greenhouse gas emissions and climate change that the Trump Administration is now attempting to revoke was the result of guidance issued by the Obama Administration in 2016. In the comment letter, the coalition asserts that the Trump Administration's draft guidance encourages agencies to violate NEPA and is arbitrary and capricious.

Students in Portland, Maine protesting to protect the environment. Photo by Jon Hinck
Enacted in 1969, NEPA is one of the nations foremost environmental statutes. NEPA requires that before any federal agency undertakes a "major federal action significantly affecting the quality of the human environment," it must consider the environmental impacts of the proposed action, alternatives to the action, and any available mitigation measures. Nearly every federal action, from the approval of significant energy and infrastructure projects to key decisions concerning the management of federal public lands, requires compliance with NEPA.

In the comment letter, the coalition asserts that the guidance encourages agencies to violate NEPA, is arbitrary and capricious, and should be withdrawn. The draft guidance moves in the wrong direction, muddying the waters on the analysis of climate change impacts under NEPA and creating new legal risks for projects subject to NEPA. The letter outlines a number of concerns, including that the draft guidance:
  • Unlawfully and arbitrarily ignores the growing body of scientific evidence pointing to the threats of climate change, and the contribution of greenhouse gas emissions to this threat;
  • Subverts the purpose and requirement of NEPA to promote informed decision-making, by disregarding climate change, the most pressing environmental issue of our time; 
  • Fails to clarify how agencies should consider indirect greenhouse gas emissions, including upstream or downstream emissions caused by projects such as pipelines and mining;
  • Includes vague and undefined terms that would allow agencies to unlawfully cast aside their obligations under NEPA and that conflict with the straightforward language of the previous 2016 guidance;
  • Unlawfully suggests that agencies may meet NEPA requirements by comparing projects' greenhouse gas emissions to other estimates and providing a qualitative summary discussion, which is insufficient;
  • Supports an unbalanced approach to cost-benefit analysis by allowing agencies to exclude the costs or quantities of climate impacts;
  • Discourages a consideration of required mitigation methods as well as the exploration of reasonable alternatives to reduce climate change; and
  • Fails to consider coordination and consistency between NEPA and state environmental analysis.
Attorney General Frey joins the coalition led by California Attorney General Xavier Becerra, which includes the attorneys general of Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Mexico, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Washington, and the District of Columbia.